Zurich, Switzerland — Financial markets may end up overvaluing the returns that artificial intelligence will deliver, Bank of England Governor Andrew Bailey has warned, laying out four ways a possible AI asset price bubble could burst and create problems for financial stability.
Bailey spoke at the University of Zurich in a lecture series run by the Swiss Institute of International Studies (SIAF). The Bank published his remarks as Central Bank independence in today’s world. He kept his opening comments short, framing them as a prompt for discussion on three themes: central bank independence, financial stability and technology.
Andrew Bailey, Governor of the Bank of England, said: “There is a lot of speculation on the subject of whether there is an asset price bubble in AI, and the financial stability risks that go with that. Bubble spotting is an imprecise science. But, let’s recognise that such a risk exists, which we should do. How might the bubble burst and potentially cause a problem? Four arguments can I think be advanced here.”
His first argument rested on what markets are built to do. Bailey said: “First, it is the job of financial markets to value uncertain future returns. The returns from AI may be good, but still markets may overvalue them. That’s in the nature of the task of valuing uncertainty.”
The second was about timing, and he reached back to the arrival of electric power to illustrate it. Bailey said: “Second, the returns may be good, and they may match expectations, but they take longer to be realised than predicted. This has been the case historically with big General Purpose Technology innovation – take Edison and electricity for instance. There are good reasons to believe that the world moves faster now, but still the timing may not live up to market expectations.”
His third and fourth points turned to winners and losers, and to public confidence. Bailey said: “Third, everyone is priced to be a winner, but history tends to tell us that this is not the case. Remember Netscape.”
He added: “Fourth, the public trust point – there is a certain fragility created by this nexus. Arguably it is not new. A British Member of Parliament was killed by one of the earliest steam locomotives, people worried about the dangers of electricity. I would argue that at present the argument seems more powerful with AI – but as I noted earlier, I treat that as a problem to be solved. But, until we have done so it could affect asset valuations.”





